Skip to main content

«  Learning Center

Pros & Cons of Solid Stains for Wood Decks

June 15th, 2024

5 min read

By Kaylea Kuhlman

Solid white stained deck next to grey house with 4 steps.

Solid stains are just one of the four types of stains for wood decks. You might think you have to choose a standard brown shade for your wooden deck. However, the options for deck stains are nearly endless.

Solid stains for decks are an opaque color which hides the grain of the wood but keeps the texture.

At Brush & Roll Painting, we have 25+ years of experience in the painting industry, so we have honed our skills and knowledge to provide top-notch services and advice to homeowners like you. Our expertise ensures that your deck will not only look great but also withstand the elements for years to come.

In this article, we will explore the pros and cons of using a solid stain for your deck, compare it to other options, and provide tips for achieving the best results for your deck. By the end, you'll have a clear understanding of whether you should choose a solid stain, the top colors to consider, and how to properly apply it to ensure your deck looks fantastic and lasts longer.

Pros of Solid Stains for Decks

Tooley After 4-2Staining a deck is a popular choice among homeowners, but not all stains are created equal. Solid stains offer a unique set of advantages that make them an excellent choice for many decks. Here are reasons to consider a solid stain:

1. Superior Deck Stain Protection

Solid stains provide a thicker, opaque finish that covers the wood grain. This creates a barrier against moisture, UV rays, and other damaging elements. This protection helps prevent issues like wood rot, mildew, and warping, which are common problems for outdoor decks.

2. Long-lasting Results

One of the main benefits of using a solid stain is its durability. Unlike transparent or semi-transparent stains, solid stains can last up to five years or more with proper maintenance. This means less frequent reapplication and more time enjoying your beautiful deck.

3. Wide Range of Colors

Solid stains come in a variety of colors, allowing you to customize the look of your deck to match your home's exterior or your personal style. Whether you prefer a classic wood tone or a bold, contemporary shade, there's a solid stain color to suit your taste.

Cons of Solid Stains for Decks

While solid stains offer many benefits, they also have a few drawbacks that might make them less suitable for certain situations. Here are some reasons you might choose a different type of stain for your deck:

1. Hides Wood Grain

One consideration for choosing solid stains is that they cover the wood grain completely. If you appreciate the natural beauty and texture of wood, a semi-transparent or transparent stain might be a better choice. These stains allow the wood's natural characteristics to show through, enhancing its organic look.

2. More Difficult to Apply

Applying a solid stain requires careful preparation and a more precise application process. The thicker consistency means the painter needs to be careful about avoiding drips and ensuring an even coat. This can make the application process more labor-intensive compared to lighter stains.

3. Limited Color Changes

Once you apply a solid stain, changing the color in the future can be challenging. The opaque nature of the stain makes it difficult to switch to a lighter color without significant preparation, such as stripping the existing stain. If you think you may want to change your deck color again in the future, a semi-transparent stain might offer more flexibility.

When to Choose a Solid Stain For Your Deck

Media 1-F40C3695-08A8-48AB-A627-14537EDC790D1. Weathered or Aged Decks

If your deck is older and has visible wear and tear, a solid stain can rejuvenate its appearance. The opaque finish covers up minor imperfections and provides a fresh, new look without the need for extensive repairs.

2. High-Traffic Areas

Wooden structures that experience heavy foot traffic, such as decks or pergolas used for entertaining or as play areas for children, benefit from the durability of a solid stain. It stands up to wear and tear better than other types of stains, ensuring your deck remains attractive and functional.

3. Desire for a Uniform Look

If you prefer a more uniform appearance with no visible wood grain, a solid stain is the way to go. It offers a consistent color that can complement your home's exterior and landscaping.

4. Protection from Harsh Weather

In Omaha, where the weather can be unpredictable and harsh, a solid stain provides the necessary protection to keep your deck looking good and lasting longer. It blocks the wood from moisture, sunlight, and high temperatures.

When to Choose a Different Type of Deck Stain

The other types of deck stains are semi-transparent, transparent, and semi-solid. Each of these stains provides a different appearance and has different benefits. If one of the factors below applies to your deck, one of these types of stains may be a better choice for you.

1. New or High-Quality Wood Decks

If you have a new deck made from high-quality wood, you might want to showcase the wood's natural beauty. In this case, a transparent or semi-transparent stain is a better option. These stains enhance the wood's natural grain and color while providing protection.

2. Minimal Maintenance Preference

For homeowners looking for a lower-maintenance option, semi-transparent stains typically require less upkeep than solid stains. They wear more naturally over time without peeling, making them easier to refresh with a new coat as needed.

3. Desire for Natural Aesthetic

If you prefer a natural, rustic look, transparent or semi-transparent stains allow the wood's natural features to shine. These stains highlight the wood's knots, grain, and variations, creating a more organic and authentic appearance.

4. Flexible Color Choices

If you like the idea of changing your deck's color more frequently, semi-transparent stains provide greater flexibility. They can be applied over existing stains more easily and come in a range of hues that enhance the wood's natural beauty without completely covering it.

Top Solid Stain Colors for Decks

Choosing the right color for your deck is essential for enhancing your outdoor space's overall look. Here are some top solid stain colors from Benjamin Moore, Sherwin-Williams, and Flood Series that work well for decks:

Benjamin Moore Colors:

  1. Benjamin Moore - "Silver Gray"

Silver Gray is a modern, sleek color that gives your deck a contemporary look. It's perfect for those who want a neutral tone that complements a wide range of exterior colors.

  1. Benjamin Moore - "Oxford Brown"

Oxford Brown provides a rich, dark finish that adds elegance and warmth to your deck. This color is ideal for creating a sophisticated outdoor space.

Sherwin-Williams Colors:

  1. Sherwin-Williams - "Charwood"

Charwood is a deep, almost-black color that offers a bold, dramatic look for your deck. It's a great choice if you want to make a strong visual statement.

  1. Sherwin-Williams - "Iron Ore"

Iron Ore is a dark gray color that exudes a modern, industrial vibe. It's perfect for homeowners looking for a contemporary, stylish deck finish.

  1. Sherwin-Williams - "Cape Cod Red"

Cape Cod Red provides a classic, rustic look that is reminiscent of traditional New England homes. It's a charming choice for those who want a touch of classic Americana.

Flood Series Colors:

  1. Flood Pro Series - "Cedar"

Cedar is a timeless option that offers a natural, warm wood look. It's perfect for those who want their deck to blend seamlessly with natural surroundings.

  1. Flood Pro Series - "Sequoia"

Sequoia is a rich, reddish-brown color that adds depth and character to your deck. It's an excellent choice for a bold yet natural appearance.

  1. Flood Pro Series - "Gray Birch"

Gray Birch offers a light, airy look that can brighten up your outdoor space. It's ideal for homeowners who prefer a clean, modern aesthetic.

Solid Deck Stains

Maintaining your deck with a solid stain is an excellent way to enhance its appearance and protect it from the elements. Solid stains offer superior protection, durability, and a wide range of color options, making them a great choice for many homeowners in Omaha.

Remember, a well-maintained deck not only looks great but also adds value to your home. 

Brush & Roll Painting in Omaha, NE, is a high-quality deck staining company in Omaha since 1996. We know just how important the right stain is for the look of your deck. When you’re investing in a part of your home, you deserve to love the results.

GET A QUOTE

If it’s your first time having a deck staining project or hiring a professional painter for one, download your deck staining project checklist. This checklist will help you be confident throughout your project, so that you can be sure you will love the final results.

Get Your Deck Staining Project Checklist

Kaylea Kuhlman

Kaylea is the Brush & Roll Painting Content Manager. Kaylea is a Journalism and Media Communications summa cum laude graduate with a minor in Marketing from the University of Nebraska at Omaha. Kaylea manages the marketing for Brush & Roll Painting.